This and the AP photos below by Dolores Ochoa show Ecuador protesters blocking the Pan Am Highway. See excerpts of the related article below.
Merri and I are used to these Ecuador protests as they are part of life in Ecuador. Though we have not seen any Ecuador demonstrations for several years, they represent a good part of the Ecuadorian way and I am proud of how the people exercise their democratic rights…. peacefully… but effectively.
The French use demonstrations as well and remember France is where many of the current ideals of democracy as we know them and processes that helped the industrial revolution really begin.
Yet the French leave cars flipped and shops burned. Remember what they did to some of their royalty! In Ecuador violence is rarely the case.
Part of Ecuador’s political problems are created because the majority of the population are very poor… and poorly educated… but they are gaining. This is Maria… excited to be headed on her first day to university to study tourism management through a scholarship provided by our foundation, Land of the Sun.
Merri and I have been in the midst of several Ecuador demonstrations. Our first protest party took place many years ago in the 1990s. We had to get a friend from Latacunga, (one of the most active places for demonstrations), to Quito airport.
There is a “moving through Ecuador road blocks art” that we learned.
Ecuadorians are by nature friendly and easy going. Violence is rare… in their protests, crime or politics. These girls attend the Topo Grande school that Land of the Sun foundation is assisting.
In that first protest adventure we were with a yatchak… in his car… a four wheel drive. This meant that a lot of the demonstration avoidance tactics came in the form of driving down railway tracks, through football fields and for quite some distance on the grassy path that formerly was the Incan trail.
Eventually however one meets a roadblock. On that trip the yatchak did most of the work. As gringos we stayed in the car and let the yatchak do the talking. Most road blocks are more like street parties… the blockers only half serious. There are generally two types of demonstrators… those with a real gripe and the majority who see the demonstration as a sort of fun time.
If you meet up with the party types… usually a dollar or two is a sufficient consideration to be able to move on IF one approaches the road block correctly… never with pushiness or aggression.
If one meets up with those who have a true grievance… the process is more difficult but usually an earnest listen to their complaint… a murmur of agreement, some sympathy and an explanation of why you need to pass through, with perhaps a dollar or two will open the block.
In that first trip, the taxi drivers had the complaint… so they were the hardest nuts to crack… but the yatchak never failed. Gentle words… appreciation for their plight and explanation of our own problems always opened the gates.
That trip to the airport took much longer than normal… one does not rush through these events… but we were able to help our friend board his plane on time.
Our second Ecuador demonstration trip took place on the day before one of our seminars in Ecuador. Talk about terrible timing!
We always met delegates when they arrive at the airport the day before the seminar so we needed to travel from Cotacachi to Quito. Normally we would make the two hour trip via the Pan American highway. But Otavalo is another major, strong point for demonstrations.
We have developed a network of friends across the country so we knew that the Pan American was tightly closed.
So we headed down the back roads with an intrepid taxi driver who knew the ropes.
At each road block I would lay down in the back seat, close my eyes and groan. Owh owh owh.
Merri, looking as pathetic as possible, rambled on “Me esposa necesita un hospital”.
The taxi driver requested clearance to the “hospital” and offered a few dollar for the favor.
This worked half way to Quito. However there are some road blocks that just cannot be passed. We found such a place where one group had dug a large pit through the road.
Another AP photo shows how some road blocks cannot circumnavigated.
Here I experienced a major recovery from my illness, grabbed our suitcase and we walk through the burning tires… NOT LOOKING ANYONE IN THE EYE.
The only hangup came when our hound dog Ma became tangled in the wires from burned tires. On the other side of the road farmers awaited with their pickups. For $20, they were willing to give us a lift into town. The normal two hour journey turned into six…. but we were there, smiling when our delegates arrived.
The demonstrations (as with those last week) lasted only a day and we accompanied our delegates on the bus back to Cotacachi next day on the Pan American highway. No one really suffered.
In short Ecuador demonstrations can range from kinda fun to frustrating… but rarely dangerous… as long as one takes their time, remains passive and avoids getting involved. These Ecuador demonstrations, are in my opinion, a good part of Ecuador’s democratic process.
I expected political tensions to tighten in January… but they seem to be winding up sooner.
Here is my thinking why there will be more political turmoil in the months ahead.
Part of Ecuador’s political problem began over 500 years ago when the Spanish began colonizing the area that is now Ecuador. The system favored a few at the expense of the majority and has remained that way.
Today the majority of the population is indigenous….but historically have had little political power and they have the smallest portion of wealth and income. Here is a resident of the village of Topo Grande.
Slowly they have become increasingly organized and must be considered as a political power that now determines elections. Yet due to the fact that they still remain among the poorest sector of the population, they also understand the global economy the least.
Almost every Ecuador president, since Merri and I began living in Ecuador, has been elected in part by making promises to poor people, like this lady above, that could not be kept.
President Correa is included in this definition and had two added benefits… his ability to speak Quichua (the indigenous language) and high oil prices when he entered office.
Oil revenues provide the major part of the government’s income and the high prices allowed Correa to keep many of his promises in his first years in office.
Then oil prices dropped and the government began cutting back.
This put so much pressure on the government income that in July 2009 it sold a billion dollars of oil to the Chinese.
An excerpt from a Reuter’s article entitled “Oil-hungry China moves to strengthen Ecuador ties” explains as it says: QUITO (Reuters) – Oil-hungry China is moving to strengthen ties with OPEC member Ecuador, part of a global trend in which the Asian giant is providing billions of dollars in financing to producer nations to guarantee energy supplies.
Ecuadorean President Rafael Correa said on Saturday the country will receive $1 billion as advance payment for future oil sales to China. Ecuador sends most of its oil to the United States, and is trying to diversify its market.
Details remained unclear on Monday. But China, the world’s second biggest petroleum consumer after the United States, is striving to cement better ties with resource-rich Ecuador.
Chinese company Sinohydro is bidding for a contract with Ecuador to build a $2 billion hydroelectric plant in the country.
In addition, the leftist Ecuadorean government says it is in talks with Chinese companies interested in investing in the Manta air base, which the U.S. Army is due to leave in September. Ecuador wants to build a commercial airport in Manta.
According to the Chinese customs office, China imported 326,000 tonnes of crude oil from Ecuador in the first four months of 2009.
Ecuador is the fifth largest producer of crude oil in South America after Venezuela, Brazil, Argentina and Colombia. It produced 486,000 barrels of crude oil a day in May.
Impoverished Ecuador faces a liquidity crunch due to low oil prices. The government’s recent debt default has shut the country off from the international capital markets.
Here is how one sharp Ecuador businessman explained the problem to me.
The government took payment now on 30% of its future oil, beginning next January to balance the current budget. How will it balance its budget next year with only 70% of its oil?
This leaves the Ecuador government only two options… higher gas prices… a factor beyond its control… or a cut back which means breaking more election promises.
That’s why it made sense to me that demonstrations would start next year not now.
However I was wrong. On hearing of the demonstrations I wrote to a network of friends and contacts across the country to get people’s opinions. Here are some of the replies I received.
Business person from Manta:
Dear Gary, Today Sunday the indigenas stared to make groups in different places of Guayaquil and especially Quito. It Iooks like they want to make strikes tomorrow and to close main roads especially in highlands areas. Until this moment everybody is quiet and nobody worries over that situation. The people are asking for solutions to water problems and something more.,
I think we have to see what happens tomorrow and hope that there is nothing more than a one day demonstration.
The Real Estate Tour in Manta was very good yesterday. The people were very nice and it looks like two couples and two men are planning to stay in Manta to see more properties.
Demonstrations have been brewing and are now taking place on two fronts.
One of them regards schoolteachers that are part of a much politicized association called UNE (Union Nacional de Educadores – or National Teachers Association) who opposes the widely celebrated regime effort to bring higher quality to public schooling via teacher examination and training.
UNE appears to be divided in this and the government is gaining ground in this legitimate endeavor.
The other front regards mostly the indigenous population (also somewhat divided), who opposes the draft for the new Water Law, claiming that it will “privatize” water, something that has no grounds.
They say that they have not been taken into account in drafting it and that it has elements for the privatization of water. Please note that the indigenous peoples of Ecuador are very dependent on natural water sources for their livelihood.
The indigenous population is adept at closing-off highways in very disruptive demonstrations.
So far it seems that the demonstrations have been mostly mild but it’s hard to tell if they will flare-up big time.
The indigenous people also oppose the new mining law on environmental grounds. The general public believes this new mining law is important as it provides environmental safeguards but also allows the exploitation of our mineral riches under a better framework. There are always tradeoffs of course.
President Correa’s Government keeps a very high level of support amongst the population and has been extremely able to defuse situations like this, even though it has had a confrontational stance.
Change brings discomfort and demonstrations are part of our culture. I hope and trust they fade away amidst inclusive dialogue.
It seems that by Tuesday the demonstrations were defused. The biggest supporters have lifted their demonstrations in order to start a dialogue process.
Some fringe groups still remain protesting but for the most the demonstrations should be over now. Best regards,
Business Person from Puerto Viejo
Hi Gary, Sorry I could not get back to you before.
As you probably know already, demonstrations have been going on this week. There are several groups such as teachers (UNE), indigenous people (CONAIE), high school and university students and other small groups who have gotten together protesting against different things they consider that violate or diminish their rights: all of them have in common their opposition to the government, although the majority of them were part of the government in the past .
Each of the group is protesting against a particular law that is about to pass in the congress: CONAIE are against Ley del Agua or a law which regulates water and that in their opinion privatizes the water. UNE or the teachers are against a new law of secondary and elementary education and also against some regulations that will reduce their salaries. Students are also against the law of university education which will not allow to have private universities in the future. Of course political parties are also involved in these demonstrations.
CONAIE is now splitt and having talks with the government so I do not expect their strike to be as strong as in the past. UNE or the teachers are the ones that seem to be stronger and they are right now in their third week of protest.
Please let me know if you need more information or comments on these issues.
How are you? I just read a little about this problem in my Country. You know I feel sad about it because the only people who suffer the consequences are the students, right now the public schools and some universities are closed, students are in their homes.
UNE (national union of teachers) is protesting for 3 reasons:
1) The Ministerio de Education did some kind of administrative process against the teachers who did not do a test (I do not what kind of test) before, this administrative process could cause a teacher to be fired, so, UNE do not accept this process.
2) Also UNE protests about the new reforms in the law that reduce 1.5% of their salary.
3) UNE protests because a new law says that school´s authorities should get a commission of service without a salary. Regards
Hi Gary, There are 2 ways to read into this:
1. Correa is trying to clean up the mess that Ecuador’s education system has grown into over the years, with UNE, the main teachers’ association becoming a by-product of the left wing political party MPD. He has run into opposition and this has lead to the UNE’s strike which started last week.
He is also trying to put some order into the way water rights are distributed and managed in the country, thus angering CONAIE (whom he no longer needs as a political support base because through the same CONAIE and Pachakutik he has gained direct access to the indigenous people by providing them housing, infrastructure, etc.).
Now it turns out that the UNE strike will tie into the CONAIE demonstrations, and things could turn nasty next week.
2. Correa has become obsessed with his power, and as such is trying to get control of every aspect of Ecuadorians’ life, including education, the use of land and water, the economy in general and of the production and industrial sector (taxing importers out of business in order to support local industry). In doing so, he has alienated many of his former allies and has made worst enemies of his former foes. This is unsustainable in the long run and the first signs that his government is heading into severe difficulties are starting to appear. As you are aware, Correa has a very aggressive political style, criticizing his opponents and trying to make anyone who does not support him look bad and ridicule. This has its cost and now Correa may be starting to pay the price.
Frankly speaking, I do not know how serious that is. The main support of Correa’s “Citizens Revolution” has been the poor people. If they start to turn against him, I do not think he will fare very well. On the other hand, these demonstrations may just be caused by a minority of UNE and CONAIE, in which case, they will pass and it will be business as usual in Ecuador. It is hard to tell at this time, but one thing that is for sure is that people are starting to run out of patience with respect to Correa. We will have a clearer picture by next Monday, because it will be possible to gauge how strong and successful CONAIE’s closing of roads turns out to be. Best,
University and high school teachers have been protesting the elimination of a 1.5% payment and a couple of other issues. These protests began last week.
This is normal in Ecuador particularly by the union involved. They like to do this in the beginning of the school year.
The police are involved which makes this more serious, but I don’t know how serious.
Gary, I do not see it so bad.
By the way, from reading the article, it is not so against the Correa-Government. Nonetheless, there has been some small protests in Ambato as well.
Gary, thanks..I am in San Clemente and no demonstrations here!
The students and the teachers have always spent most of the time demonstrating..but of course the government thought they would avoid demonstrations against them with the “peoples revolution” slogan..
The indigenous people seem to want to march again against the new mining law and the governments intent to start big scale mining operations to improve finances..
I do not think any of these demonstrations will be even close in size to what they used to be during previous governments..basically because all these movements supported the government and it’s policy and many still do..They also lack the charismatic leaders they once had.
This last comment seems to be supported by excerpts of an Associated Press article entitled “Ecuador Indian group protests water, mining laws”: The Associated Press QUITO, Ecuador — Hundreds of Indians blocked Ecuador’s Pan American highway in several provinces Monday with rocks, tree trunks and burning tires to protest new water, mining and oil laws.
Their leaders suspended the protest late Monday, saying the government had promised to talk about their objections.
The Indians contend the proposed the laws threaten their lands and will privatize water resources. Leftist President Rafael Correa disputes that view, and the ruling party-controlled legislature has been expected to approve the laws.
Monday’s protests on the main national highway paled in comparison to protests that ousted Ecuadorean presidents in 2000 and 2005.
Third AP photo from this article.
Things are improving. Ecuador’s indigenous are getting richer and better educated.
Enrique is one of the excellent Cotacachi indigenous builders who is developing homes in Cotacachi. He is among a growing sector of hard working, highly successful and dependable indigenous businesses that help form a strong, integrated middle class in Ecuador. Be sure see to see some of Enrique’s houses at this site next week.
Ecuador demonstrations are a part of Ecuador’s democratic process. Since moving to Ecuador I have seen many presidents comes and many go… very few serving their full term… a process I like better than having a bad president last. President Correa has enjoyed a time without Ecuador protests because of high oil prices and his willingness to default on Ecuador bonds. That former decision is now biting him back… along with low oil prices… so more and more are saying… “throw the bum out”.
Wouldn’t it be nice if we could do this at home?
Combining good international investing with the greatest asset of all, the ability to earn wherever you live, brings everlasting wealth.
This is why we offer our course Tangled Web… How to Have an Internet Business.
A clear mind and healthy body are also a vital assets… plus a second language is a powerful diversification tool.
This is why I am willing to pay you $300 to attend either our Ecuador Super Thinking plus Spanish seminar in September or our North Carolina International Business & Investing seminar in October. Sign up for either seminar and I will email you our Tangled Web… How to Have an Internet Business Course (offered at $299) free plus I’ll knock an extra dollar off your seminar fee…. to round up the $300 savings.
See details of the two seminar below.
Delegates at our Ecuador seminars and tours enjoy Ecuador music.
Join Merri, Thomas Fischer of JGAM, our webmaster David Cross and me in North Carolina this October and enroll in our emailed course on how to have a web business free. Save $300.
Learn more about global investing, how to have an international business and diversification in Ecuador at the seminar.
Oct. 9-11 IBEZ North Carolina
Here is an email for a recent seminar delegate: Hello Gary and Merri, I have wanted to write to tell you how much we enjoyed your IBEZ seminar, and to thank you both for inviting us all into your lovely home for lunch last Sunday. Merri, again, thank you for taking the time to prepare foods especially for me; they were delicious, and I appreciate your effort! Thank you for a thoroughly enjoyable, very well done, stimulating seminar. I came away not only with all the notes provided, but also with many ideas which I plan to begin working on now that we are back home. Wishing you all the best,
Or join us in Ecuador and learn more about living and retiring in Ecuador.
We take delegates on our Ecuador seminars to Otavalo markets. Many buy enough goods to resell in North America to pay for their entire trip. Ecuador textiles like these I photographed in Otavalo are popular.
Here are comments from one seminar delegate about the followup from our course: Gary & Merri -
I know why I get a ‘warm and fuzzy’ feeling when I see your two names in the ‘From’ column of my emails! I sincerely hope that others are getting that same satisfaction. Thank you both again for the help and assistance in getting to Ecuador.
October 16-18 Ecuador Southern coastal tour Sold Out
Oct. 21-24 Ecuador Import Export Tour
Oct. 25-26 Imbabura Real Estate Tour
Nov. 6-8 IBEZ Ecuador Seminar
Nov. 9-10 Imbabura Real Estate Tour
December 6-8 Beyond Logic Shamanic Tour
December 9-10 Imbabura Real Estate Tour
Attend any two Ecuador seminar or tours in a calendar month…$949 for one. $1,349 for two.
Attend any three Ecuador courses or tours in a calendar month…$1,199 for one. $1,799 for two.
“Oil-hungry China moves to strengthen Ecuador tieswww.reuters.com/article/GCA-Oil/idUSTRE56C6FF20090713
Ecuador Indian group protests water, mining laws